In a strange land

Report from Narnia #1

Thursday 8 May 2008 · 9 Comments

As promised (scroll through to the end), the first report from Narnia. I started reading the Narnia books to my three girls a couple of weeks ago. I’m hoping to get through to the end of Prince Caspian before the film is released; not only do I want them to know the story first, or it could be a bit too much for the Misses Six, but I want them to regard the book as the ‘true’ story, and the film as an interpretation.

We read The Magician’s Nephew without a single comment about the metaphysics of possible worlds, which I found terribly disappointing. The girls accepted the story, lock, stock, and rings - no questions asked. This is probably a good thing; they had no sense that Aslan ought to be identified with the god of the Christians. And having brought them up with a creation story that begins with the big bang, goes through the formation of the galaxy and the solar system, and then proceeds through evolution, all courtesy of Mr Strange Land, my guess is that they have no propensity to buy into myth-making anyway.

They find The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe much more engaging. No doubt they all think they are Lucy. And this evening, just after we reached the point where all the children leapt into the Wardrobe to avoid Mrs Macready, the younger Miss Six found a perfect way to torment the elder Miss Six.

We had read the nightly chapter, and I shooed them all off to take out their hair ties, and get into bed. A few minutes later, I followed them, to sing the nightly lullaby and tuck them in. (Alas, Miss Nine no longer wants me to sing to her, but she still likes me to come by, and as a matter of ritual, instruct her not to read too late.)

As I went into the Miss Sixes’ bedroom, I found the younger Miss Six scrabbling around in the wardrobe, pushing her way past the dresses and shoes, and obviously hoping, just hoping. She scrambled out, and hopped into bed. “Hoping to get into Narnia, were you?” I asked her.

“Oh no,” she replied. “I was there.”

“No you weren’t,” half-scoffed, half-yearned the elder Miss Six.

“I was too,” the younger one replied. And she continued to insist that she had been there, and it had only seemed like a moment in our world, but she had been there for hours and hours. The elder Miss Six was quite put out. On the one hand, she knew that the younger Miss Six couldn’t possibly have been here; on the other, she would like to believe it was possible; on the gripping hand, why on earth should the younger Miss Six go when she hadn’t! The elder Miss Six has a very finely attuned sense of justice, when it comes to her entitlements.

I think I will have to find a poster map of Narnia, and pin it to the back wall of their wardrobe. Or two copies; I think Miss Nine will want one too.

Categories: Books · Family · Parenting

9 responses so far ↓

  • Malcolm // Thursday 8 May 2008 at 10:06 pm

    “…on the gripping hand…” Frak me! That was put in there just for Craig Ranapia, wasn’t it?

  • Deborah // Thursday 8 May 2008 at 10:16 pm

    Craig can’t be the only person who will recognise it. Che? Stephen? Julie? MTNW? Maybe even Melika?

  • Paul // Friday 9 May 2008 at 4:44 am

    “…on the gripping hand…” Please explain for those of us from the shallow end of the talent pool.

  • Stephen Judd // Friday 9 May 2008 at 4:58 am

    Er… no? I could use Google, but that would be cheating.

    (OK, I gave in and googled. I DID read TMIGE about 25 years ago; apparently those synapses died).

  • littlegemsession // Friday 9 May 2008 at 7:38 am

    We read “Northern Lights” and “Nim’s Island” before going to see the movies for the same reasons, it was interesting. My nearly 7yo picked up difference and said he liked the books because the pictures “come inside your head”. Mind you “Northern Lights” was hacked to bits!

  • Melika // Friday 9 May 2008 at 9:01 am

    “on the gripping hand”
    but of course I recognise it…….as a very old/experienced/mature science fiction reader.

  • Melika // Friday 9 May 2008 at 9:10 am

    “The metaphysics of possible worlds”

    At 6 years I think they are still at the stage of almost anything and everything still being possible, and still credit the written word with a modicum of truth.

  • Che Tibby // Saturday 10 May 2008 at 1:09 pm

    nope. got me there. i had to google it to.

    but i have a vague memory of a story involving that.

  • Julie // Monday 12 May 2008 at 9:24 am

    *Wooosh*

    For once not the sound of deadlines going past (10 points to whoever gets that one), but indeed the discussion of the gripping hand reference. I just thought you had accidentally left a superfluous p in ;-)

    But then in my defence I haven’t read the book in question. Which probably just makes it worse.

    I can definitely identify with the fervent wish that Narnia could be real. I think that’s one of the reasons that the Harry Potter books (and movies) entrance me despite many good reasons that they shouldn’t - because they put forth a world (in fact our world) in which magic is real. Sigh.

Leave a Comment